Montana TODD and the One-Year Title Insurance Lockup Surviving Spouses Must Know About

Your spouse spent years making sure the house would pass directly to you when they died. They had an attorney prepare a Transfer on Death Deed, they got it notarized, they paid the recording fee at the County Clerk's office. When they died, the deed worked exactly as designed — the property transferred to your name outside of probate, without a judge, without a court filing fee, without waiting months for estate administration to close.

And then you tried to sell it, or refinance it, and discovered a problem nobody told you about: Montana title insurance companies routinely refuse to issue policies on TODD-transferred property for up to one year after the date of death.

Understanding why this happens — and what your options are — is one of the most practically important things a surviving spouse in Montana can know.

Why the TODD Creates a Title Insurance Problem

A Transfer on Death Deed is governed by Montana's Uniform Real Property Transfer on Death Act (MCA 72-6-415). It allows a property owner to designate beneficiaries who will receive real estate automatically at death, without the property passing through probate.

The problem is that bypassing probate is exactly what creates the title insurance gap.

In a standard probate process, the personal representative publishes a Notice to Creditors in a local newspaper for three consecutive weeks. That notice triggers a strict four-month window during which creditors must file claims against the estate. Once that window closes, creditors are barred from pursuing the property. A title insurance underwriter can look at the probate record, see that the creditor claim period has passed, and issue a clean policy with confidence.

When a TODD is used, none of that happens. No creditor notice is published. No formal claim period runs. Under Montana law, creditors retain the ability to pursue claims against real property transferred by a TODD for one year after the owner's death. Title insurance underwriters know this. Their actuarial models treat that one-year window as an unquantifiable risk. Rather than absorb it, most Montana title companies simply decline to issue policies on TODD-transferred property until the year has elapsed.

For a surviving spouse who needs to sell the home — because the mortgage is unaffordable on one income, because they are relocating, or because the property needs to be liquidated for living expenses — this lockup can be financially devastating.

What You Need to Do After the TODD Transfers

Even though the TODD transfers title automatically at death, the transfer is not self-executing in the public record. As the surviving beneficiary, you must take specific steps to formalize your ownership.

You need to file a Realty Transfer Certificate (RTC) with the county. This document, along with the recorded TODD and a certified copy of the death certificate, is how the county assessor and subsequent purchasers verify that the transfer has occurred. Failure to file the RTC can create complications when you eventually try to sell or refinance.

Filing the RTC does not start the one-year clock — that begins on the date of death, regardless of when you file your paperwork. But you should file it promptly to protect your ownership record.

Options When You Cannot Wait a Year

If you need to sell or refinance the property before the one-year period expires, you have a few options worth understanding.

Option 1: Open Informal Probate Voluntarily

This is the strategic workaround that estate attorneys and title underwriters know about, but that most surviving spouses discover too late.

Even though the property passed outside of probate through the TODD, you can voluntarily open an informal probate proceeding in the District Court to clear the title insurance problem. The $100 filing fee opens a case. Once a personal representative is appointed, they must publish a Notice to Creditors for three consecutive weeks in a local newspaper. That publication starts the four-month creditor claim clock. After four months pass with no valid claims, the estate can be closed — and a title insurance company now has a clean record showing that creditors had their window and did not step forward.

The total timeline from filing to clear title is approximately five to six months — still faster than waiting the full year. And you gain the additional benefit of the statutory allowances: as the surviving spouse, you are entitled to the $22,500 Homestead Allowance, up to $15,000 in Exempt Property, and up to $27,000 in Family Allowance, which can shield estate assets from creditor claims during the process.

Option 2: Negotiate with Individual Title Companies

Not every title company applies the one-year rule with equal rigidity. Some underwriters will issue policies with specific exceptions noted, or will accept indemnification agreements from heirs. This is case-by-case and depends heavily on which title company is involved, who the underlying underwriter is, and what the estate's debt profile looks like. If the deceased had no known creditors, no outstanding medical debt, and a modest estate, some companies will negotiate.

This is not reliable enough to count on if you have a fixed timeline for a sale, but it is worth raising with any title company you approach.

Option 3: Wait Out the Year

If the property is not underwater and you can afford to hold it, simply waiting the twelve months is the lowest-effort option. Keep the property maintained, continue paying property taxes and insurance in your name, and allow the creditor window to expire naturally. At the twelve-month mark, title companies can issue policies without restriction.

What to Watch for with Montana Medicaid Estate Recovery

If your spouse received Montana Medicaid benefits — particularly long-term nursing home care or home and community-based services — the state's Department of Public Health and Human Services has a claim against the estate for the cost of that care. Under federal law, Montana is required to pursue estate recovery.

A TODD does not necessarily protect the property from this claim. While the presence of a surviving spouse defers recovery (the state cannot move against the property while you are living in it), Montana retains the right to recover from your estate if you die within three years of your spouse's death. This is the "three-year spousal look-forward" rule. If Medicaid estate recovery is a concern, you should consult an elder law attorney before taking any steps to sell or transfer the property.

The Practical Sequence for TODD Recipients

If you have inherited property through a Transfer on Death Deed, work through this sequence before making any decisions about the property:

1. Obtain certified copies of the death certificate from DPHHS Vital Records ($16 per copy — order at least ten).
2. File the Realty Transfer Certificate at the County Clerk and Recorder along with the recorded TODD and a certified death certificate.
3. Contact your spouse's mortgage servicer, homeowners insurance carrier, and property tax authority to update account information.
4. Assess the estate's creditor situation. If your spouse had significant medical debt, credit card debt, or outstanding obligations, consider consulting a probate attorney before any sale.
5. If you need to sell within twelve months, evaluate whether voluntary informal probate makes sense given your timeline and the estate's size.

How This Fits into Your Broader Benefits Picture

The TODD one-year lockup is one of several traps that Montana's otherwise survivor-friendly legal framework contains. It is the kind of problem that appears simple on paper — the deed transferred the house to you, so you should be able to sell it — but produces real financial consequences when you encounter it in practice.

The Montana Survivor Benefits Navigator covers this issue alongside the full sequence of asset transfers, statutory allowances, and creditor protection strategies that surviving spouses need to execute in the months following a death. Understanding how probate and non-probate pathways interact is essential for protecting what your spouse worked to leave behind.

See more Montana guides →