Kentucky Dower, Curtesy, and the Elective Share: Surviving Spouse Rights in Probate

Kentucky is one of the few remaining states that still enforces dower and curtesy rights — a legal framework rooted in centuries of common law property protections for surviving spouses. In practical terms, what this means today is straightforward and significant: a surviving spouse in Kentucky cannot be disinherited. Regardless of what a will says, the law guarantees them a minimum share of the estate.

If you are an executor in a blended family situation — or a surviving spouse who received far less than you expected under a will — you need to understand exactly how this works.

What Are Dower and Curtesy?

Historically, "dower" referred to a widow's right to a portion of her deceased husband's property; "curtesy" was the corresponding right for a widower. Kentucky's modern statutes, codified in KRS Chapter 392, have evolved these concepts into what is now effectively a spousal elective share — the right of a surviving spouse to reject the provisions of a will and take a statutory percentage of the estate instead.

The terms dower and curtesy are still used in Kentucky legal practice, but they now operate as the mechanism that delivers the elective share rather than as separate independent rights.

The Elective Share: What a Renouncing Spouse Receives

When a surviving spouse elects against the will — formally renounces it — they are entitled to:

Personal property: An absolute estate in one-half of the decedent's surplus personal property. "Surplus" means whatever remains after payment of the estate's debts and administration expenses.

Real estate: An estate in fee simple of one-third of all real property the decedent owned at the time of death.

These are not life estates or limited interests — they are outright ownership. A spouse who elects against the will and claims the real estate elective share becomes a full one-third owner of the property, with all the rights that entails: the right to use it, lease it, sell their interest, or force a partition sale.

The Six-Month Renunciation Deadline

A surviving spouse does not have unlimited time to decide. Under KRS 392.080, the renunciation must be filed within six months of the date the will is admitted to probate. The filing must be made:

1. With the probate court clerk in the county where the estate is being administered, and
2. With the county clerk of the same county.

Filing with only one of these offices is not sufficient. Both filings are required.

Once this six-month window closes without a renunciation, the surviving spouse has waived their elective share rights for that estate. They receive only what the will provides — which may be nothing, or may be far less than the statutory one-third and one-half.

If the decedent died intestate (without a will), the elective share framework is less relevant because Kentucky's intestate succession statutes independently guarantee the surviving spouse a substantial portion of the estate. The elective share is primarily a protection against disinheritance by will.

Why This Creates Serious Problems for Executors

The elective share is a strategic vulnerability in estate administration, particularly in:

Blended families: If the decedent was in a second marriage and intended to leave the family home to children from a previous marriage, a surviving spouse who renounces the will immediately becomes a one-third fee simple owner of that home. The children cannot simply sell the property without the spouse's cooperation.

Real estate titles: Any real estate transfer, sale, or refinancing that occurs without accounting for the surviving spouse's potential elective share rights may be legally defective. Title companies routinely ask whether the surviving spouse has renounced the will or explicitly confirmed they accept its provisions.

Estate accounting: Until the spouse decides — renounce or accept — the executor cannot finalize distributions. The entire distribution algorithm changes depending on whether the elective share is invoked.

What Executors Must Do

If the decedent left a surviving spouse and the will does not provide generously for them, the executor should:

1. Inform the spouse of their elective share rights and the six-month deadline — while making clear you are providing information, not legal advice.

2. Do not transfer real estate until the renunciation window has closed or the spouse has formally confirmed they accept the will's provisions.

3. Do not make final distributions to other beneficiaries until the spouse's position is clear.

4. Consult a probate attorney immediately if the spouse signals they intend to renounce. The recalculation of distributions, particularly when real estate is involved, is complex enough that professional guidance is warranted.

The Limits of the Elective Share

The elective share cannot be used to circumvent a pre-nuptial agreement that validly waives dower and curtesy rights. If the parties executed a properly drafted and executed ante-nuptial agreement under KRS 392.020, those waivers are enforceable.

The elective share also does not automatically capture all assets the decedent transferred during their lifetime. However, if the decedent made transfers specifically designed to defeat the spouse's elective share rights — a practice courts scrutinize closely — complex fraudulent conveyance litigation can result.

For surviving spouses wondering whether to renounce the will, this decision deserves careful legal advice before the six-month window expires. The financial difference between accepting a will's provisions and claiming the statutory elective share can amount to hundreds of thousands of dollars.

The Kentucky Probate Process Guide covers surviving spouse rights, the renunciation filing process, and the practical steps executors must take when a spouse signals intent to claim the elective share.

See more Kentucky guides →