Passing of Accounts vs Executor Release in Newfoundland and Labrador

The final stage of estate administration in Newfoundland and Labrador involves accounting to the beneficiaries for everything that happened to the estate's money. Most executors dread this step, largely because they've heard of something called a "passing of accounts" — which sounds expensive and complicated. The good news is that the vast majority of estates never need to go through a formal passing of accounts, because there is a much simpler alternative: the executor release.

What Is a Passing of Accounts?

A passing of accounts is a formal court audit of the executor's financial management of the estate. It involves filing detailed accounts with the Supreme Court of Newfoundland and Labrador, notifying all beneficiaries that an audit is being conducted, and appearing before a judge who reviews whether every income and expense was proper.

The Trustee Act of Newfoundland and Labrador and the Rules of the Supreme Court, 1986 (Rule 56) require executors to maintain meticulous records of all transactions. The passing of accounts is the ultimate enforcement mechanism — a public hearing where beneficiaries can challenge specific line items, question the executor's management decisions, and ask the court to reduce the executor's compensation.

A formal passing of accounts is time-consuming, costly, and legally complex. For smaller or uncomplicated estates, it can cost more in legal fees than the value of any disputed amounts. Which is exactly why the executor release exists.

The Executor Release: Form 56.29A

The Form of Release (Form 56.29A) is the alternative to a formal passing of accounts. Instead of a court audit, the executor prepares a detailed Final Account — a clear summary of all assets collected, all debts paid, all expenses incurred, and the final distribution to each beneficiary. Every adult beneficiary reviews this accounting and, if they are satisfied, signs the Form of Release and an accompanying Affidavit of Execution of a Release (Form 56.29B).

Once executed releases are filed with the Supreme Court, a judge can issue an order dispensing with the formal passing of accounts and discharging the executor from their duties. The estate is legally closed.

The release route requires:

• All adult beneficiaries must agree (unanimous consent)
• Each beneficiary must have received or been offered their full entitlement
• The Final Account must be reasonably comprehensive — beneficiaries are signing away the right to a court audit, so they need enough information to make that decision meaningfully

If any beneficiary refuses to sign or cannot be located, you cannot use the release route for that beneficiary's portion. You may need to proceed with a partial passing of accounts or obtain a court order.

What the Final Account Should Include

Your Final Account doesn't need to be an accountant's masterpiece, but it should be clear and complete enough that any beneficiary reading it understands what happened to the estate:

• Opening inventory value at date of death
• All assets collected and their sale proceeds (real estate, vehicles, investments)
• All income received during estate administration (interest, rent, etc.)
• All debts paid (mortgage discharge, credit cards, utilities, medical bills)
• Funeral expenses paid from the estate
• Probate court fees paid
• Professional fees (solicitor, accountant) paid from the estate
• Executor compensation being claimed
• Final balance available for distribution
• Each beneficiary's entitlement and the amount to be paid or paid already

Executor Compensation

Before distribution and before requesting releases, executors can claim compensation for their time. Under Section 88 of the Trustee Act, the compensation must be "fair and reasonable." The Act sets a statutory cap of 5% of the gross realized value of the estate for the capital administration fee, plus an annual care and management fee not exceeding 0.4% of the average market value of assets for each year the estate remained open.

In practice, courts rarely award the maximum 5% unless the estate was genuinely complex and time-consuming. For a straightforward estate, executor fees of 1–3% of the gross value are more typical. The compensation is taxable income to the executor and must be disclosed to beneficiaries before they sign releases.

If beneficiaries disagree with the proposed compensation, they can refuse to sign releases and force a passing of accounts — which is why negotiating the compensation amount before circulating the releases saves significant conflict.

When You Actually Need a Formal Passing of Accounts

The release route doesn't work in every situation:

• A beneficiary is a minor (under 19 in NL) and their legal guardian or the Public Trustee won't consent on their behalf
• A beneficiary lacks legal capacity and has no authorized representative
• Beneficiaries are in active dispute with the executor about how the estate was managed
• The executor wants court protection against a future claim from a beneficiary who is currently uncontactable
• CRA has indicated outstanding tax issues that haven't been resolved

In these situations, a formal passing of accounts before a Supreme Court judge is the path to finalization. A solicitor experienced in estate law should guide this process.

The Sequence for Closing the Estate

1. Obtain CRA Clearance Certificate (file terminal T1, wait for assessment, apply for clearance)
2. Pay all remaining debts and expenses
3. Calculate executor compensation
4. Prepare Final Account
5. Share Final Account with all adult beneficiaries
6. Collect signed Form 56.29A (Release) and Form 56.29B (Affidavit of Execution) from each
7. File executed releases with the Supreme Court
8. Court issues discharge order
9. Distribute net estate to beneficiaries
10. Close estate bank account

The Newfoundland and Labrador Estate Settlement Guide includes a Final Account template and the full closing sequence, including the CRA Clearance Certificate process that must precede distribution.

See more Newfoundland and Labrador guides →