Proof of Will in Newfoundland: Witness Requirements and What Happens When They're Gone

You have found the will. The deceased named you as executor. Now you need to take this document to the Supreme Court of Newfoundland and Labrador and get Letters of Probate — the official authority you need to access bank accounts, transfer property, and close the estate.

The first thing the court will ask for is not the will itself. It is proof that the will was properly executed. And that proof must come from a specific person: one of the witnesses who watched the deceased sign.

This requirement catches many executors off guard, especially when the will was signed years or decades ago and the witnesses are elderly, have moved away, or have died. Here is exactly what the court requires, and what happens when the standard path is not available.

Why Newfoundland Requires Proof of Execution

A will can be forged. Names can be added after the fact. Dates can be altered. The court's insistence on execution proof is not bureaucratic obstruction — it is the mechanism that protects beneficiaries, creditors, and the estate from fraud.

Under the Rules of the Supreme Court, 1986, obtaining a Grant of Letters of Probate requires the filing of a Proof of Will — specifically, Form 56.11A. This is a sworn affidavit completed by one of the original witnesses to the will, attesting that they watched the testator (the person making the will) sign the document, that the testator appeared to be of sound mind and free from duress, and that the witness's own signature on the will is genuine.

The affidavit must be sworn before a commissioner of oaths, a notary public, or a registry clerk.

Will Execution Requirements in Newfoundland and Labrador

For a will to be valid in Newfoundland and Labrador, it must meet these execution requirements:

The testator must sign the will (or direct another person to sign on their behalf in their presence, if they are physically unable to sign themselves).

Two witnesses must be present simultaneously when the testator signs. Both witnesses must watch the signing happen — one witness leaving the room while the other witnesses the signature is not valid.

Both witnesses must then sign the will in the testator's presence.

Witnesses cannot be beneficiaries. If a witness to the will is also a person who stands to benefit from it, that witness's gift under the will is voided, even if the will itself remains valid. This rule prevents the obvious conflict of interest that would arise if beneficiaries could validate their own inheritance.

Spouses of beneficiaries are similarly disqualified from acting as witnesses without the risk of voiding the corresponding gift.

These requirements apply to standard attested wills. The rules are different for holograph wills — wills written entirely in the testator's own handwriting — which are addressed separately.

Completing Form 56.11A: What the Witness Must Do

When you locate a witness, they need to complete Form 56.11A, the Proof of Will affidavit. The form asks the witness to confirm:

• Their full name and address
• That they knew the testator personally
• That they were present when the testator signed the will on the date shown
• That the testator appeared to be of sound mind and memory
• That the testator signed voluntarily, without apparent duress or undue influence
• That the witness's signature on the will is their genuine signature
• That they signed in the presence of the testator

The form is sworn — meaning the witness signs it in front of a commissioner of oaths or notary public, who then stamps or seals it. The original completed form is submitted to the Supreme Court Registry along with the Petition for Probate (Form 56.05A).

Only one witness needs to complete this affidavit, even though two witnessed the signing. If you can locate either witness, that is sufficient.

When the Witnesses Cannot Be Found

This is where estates get complicated, and where many executors first realize they need legal assistance.

Witness has died. If the witness is deceased, they obviously cannot swear an affidavit. This is more common than people expect — wills signed 20 or 30 years ago often have witnesses who have since passed away.

Witness cannot be located. The witness may have moved provincially or internationally, and attempts to find them have failed.

Both witnesses are unavailable. In some cases, neither witness can be found or is alive.

In these situations, the executor cannot use the standard Form 56.11A process. The Supreme Court requires alternative evidence of proper execution, and this is the point where a solicitor becomes essential.

Depending on the circumstances, the alternative evidence might include:

• An affidavit from someone who was present at the execution, even if they were not a formal witness, who can attest to having seen the signing take place
• Handwriting analysis evidence identifying the testator's and witnesses' signatures as genuine
• In some cases, specialized court forms designed for specific non-standard situations (for example, Form 56.11B for holograph wills, or Form 56.11A adapted for situations where the testator signed with a mark rather than a full signature)

None of these alternatives are simple paperwork exercises. They involve drafting non-standard affidavits, potentially engaging document experts, and presenting the evidence in a way that satisfies the court's evidentiary requirements. Courts have the discretion to accept alternative evidence, but they will not do so on the basis of bare assertion. The evidence must be cogent.

Holograph Wills: Different Rules, Same Challenges

A holograph will is one written entirely in the testator's handwriting and signed by them. No witnesses are required for a holograph will to be valid in Newfoundland and Labrador.

However, proving a holograph will in court still requires evidence. Because there are no witnesses to provide Form 56.11A, the executor must instead prove that the document is in the deceased's handwriting — typically through an affidavit from someone with personal knowledge of the testator's handwriting, or through handwriting analysis.

The executor must submit Form 56.11B (Affidavit Proving Execution of a Holograph Will) rather than Form 56.11A. If handwriting evidence is contested, the court may require expert analysis.

This is one reason that holograph wills, while legally valid, often create more administrative difficulty than properly witnessed wills. The savings in legal fees at the drafting stage can result in significantly greater costs and delays at the probate stage.

What Happens If There Is No Proof at All

If the executor genuinely cannot satisfy the court's evidentiary requirements — cannot locate witnesses, cannot find anyone with knowledge of the signing, and cannot produce credible handwriting evidence — the court may refuse to grant Letters of Probate.

This leaves the estate in an extremely difficult position. Without a Grant of Probate, the executor has no formal legal authority over the estate's assets. Banks will not release funds. The Registry of Deeds will not register property transfers. The estate is effectively frozen.

At this point, depending on the circumstances, it may be possible to apply for Letters of Administration with Will Annexed — a form of administration that treats the problematic will as guidance while granting court authority on different grounds — or to apply for Letters of Administration as if the deceased died intestate, in which case the Intestate Succession Act distribution rules apply.

Neither path is straightforward. Both require legal assistance to navigate.

Practical Steps Before You File

Before submitting your probate application, take these steps:

Locate both witnesses' contact information. The will itself may list their addresses at the time of signing. Family members, the solicitor who drafted the will, or old correspondence may provide current contact information.

Reach out to either witness directly. Explain that you are the named executor and need them to swear a short affidavit. Most witnesses understand this is a routine step and cooperate.

If a witness is deceased, obtain their death certificate. This documents for the court why the standard process is unavailable and establishes the basis for requesting alternative evidence.

If neither witness can be found, consult a solicitor before filing anything with the court. Submitting an incomplete application can slow the process and complicate the eventual resolution.

The Newfoundland and Labrador Estate Settlement Guide covers the full probate filing sequence — Form 56.04A through the final Grant of Letters of Probate — including the mandatory five-day waiting period after the Notice of Application and the court fee structure ($60 for the first $1,000 of estate value, plus $0.60 per $100 thereafter). If you are managing the administration on your own, it maps the complete process step by step.

For the specific challenge of missing witnesses or problematic wills, that is one of the defined escalation points where a solicitor's involvement is the right call before you invest time in an application the court will reject.

See more Newfoundland and Labrador guides →