Taxes on Survivor Benefits in Vermont: What You Owe and What You Don't

Not all survivor benefits are created equal when it comes to taxes. A surviving spouse in Vermont might receive a life insurance payout, a weekly workers' compensation check, a state pension, and a lump-sum emergency benefit in the same year — and each of those is taxed completely differently. Getting this wrong means either overpaying taxes you don't owe or facing a surprise bill the following April.

Here's the breakdown by benefit type.

Life Insurance Proceeds: Generally Tax-Free

Life insurance death benefits paid to a named beneficiary are generally not subject to Vermont income tax or federal income tax. The beneficiary receives the proceeds tax-free because the benefit is not considered income — it is a contractual payment triggered by death.

There are limited exceptions. If the policy was transferred for value in a business transaction, the excess above the consideration paid may be taxable. If the surviving spouse chooses to leave the proceeds with the insurer under a settlement option and earns interest on the accumulated amount, that interest income is taxable in the year it accrues.

One Vermont-specific concern: life insurance passes to beneficiaries entirely outside of probate. This means it is not included in the decedent's probate estate for purposes of the Vermont estate tax calculation. However, it is included in the gross estate for estate tax purposes if the decedent held incidents of ownership in the policy at death. This distinction matters for large estates approaching Vermont's $5,000,000 threshold.

Workers' Compensation Death Benefits: Tax-Free

Weekly indemnity payments to surviving dependents under Vermont's workers' compensation death benefit statute are not subject to federal or Vermont income tax. The same tax exemption applies to the burial expense reimbursements paid to the estate or family (up to $10,000 in Vermont).

This tax-exempt status is a significant advantage over ordinary wage replacement, and it is worth communicating clearly to surviving families managing a tight budget. The full check from the workers' compensation insurer is the net check — no withholding, no quarterly estimated payments required on this income.

Survivors' Pension from VSERS or VSTRS: Taxable Income

Pension payments received from the Vermont State Employees' Retirement System (VSERS) or Vermont State Teachers' Retirement System (VSTRS) are taxable as ordinary income at both the federal and Vermont state levels. The surviving spouse receives a 1099-R from the Retirement Office each January showing the total benefit received during the prior year.

The surviving spouse should file a W-4VT with the Retirement Office to set appropriate Vermont income tax withholding. Failing to set up withholding can result in a significant Vermont income tax bill at year-end, along with potential underpayment penalties. Vermont's income tax rates follow a progressive bracket structure; a surviving spouse receiving a substantial pension benefit may find themselves in a higher bracket than expected, particularly if they have other income sources.

The interaction with Social Security is also worth understanding. If the surviving spouse receives both Social Security survivor benefits and a state pension, up to 85% of the Social Security benefit may become taxable for federal purposes depending on combined income levels. Vermont conforms to the federal Social Security income inclusion rules, so a portion of the Social Security benefit may also become Vermont taxable income in higher-income scenarios.

Social Security Survivor Benefits: Partially Taxable Depending on Income

Social Security survivor benefits follow the same taxation rules as regular Social Security retirement benefits. Whether any portion is taxable depends on the surviving spouse's "combined income" — adjusted gross income plus non-taxable interest plus half of Social Security benefits.

• If combined income is below $25,000 (single filer), Social Security benefits are not taxable.
• Between $25,000 and $34,000, up to 50% of benefits may be taxable.
• Above $34,000, up to 85% of benefits may be taxable.

Vermont follows the federal Social Security inclusion rules, meaning the same percentage taxable federally is taxable in Vermont. A surviving spouse with a state pension, investment income, and Social Security should expect to owe Vermont income tax on a portion of the Social Security payment.

Vermont Estate Tax: The $5 Million Threshold and No Portability

Vermont imposes its own estate tax on the transfer of estates from deceased Vermont residents and nonresidents who owned Vermont real estate. For deaths occurring in 2021 or later, the estate tax applies to the portion of the gross estate that exceeds $5,000,000. The tax rate is a flat 16% on the excess.

An estate with a gross value of $6,000,000 would owe Vermont estate tax of 16% on $1,000,000 — that's $160,000 in Vermont estate tax, due within nine months of the date of death on Form EST-191.

The portability problem. The federal estate tax system allows a surviving spouse to use any unused portion of the deceased spouse's federal estate tax exemption — a concept called portability. Vermont does not allow portability. Vermont law provides no mechanism for the surviving spouse to use the deceased spouse's unused $5,000,000 Vermont estate tax exemption.

This has real consequences for dual-income couples and owners of substantial Vermont farmland or real estate. If one spouse dies with a modest estate and leaves everything to the surviving spouse (which typically qualifies for the marital deduction and avoids immediate estate tax), the surviving spouse now holds the combined assets. When the second spouse dies, their estate may well exceed $5,000,000 — and they have no access to the first spouse's unused exemption. The full excess is taxed at 16%.

The proper planning response — for couples concerned about this — is a credit shelter trust (also called a bypass trust) that uses the first spouse's exemption at the first death rather than deferring it. This planning must happen before death, not after. If the first spouse has already died, it is too late to restructure the exemption usage.

Vermont Fiduciary Income Tax: What the Estate Itself Owes

While the estate exists as a legal entity during administration, any income it generates is taxable to the estate on Vermont Form FIT-161. This is separate from the estate tax and from the decedent's final personal income tax return.

Taxable estate income includes interest, dividends, rental income from estate property, capital gains from asset sales, and IRA distributions liquidated during probate. The fiduciary return is required for each calendar year the estate remains open and generates income.

The estate cannot be closed — and the probate court will not issue a final decree of distribution — until the executor obtains Vermont Form E-2A Tax Clearance from the Department of Taxes. That clearance requires all income tax returns (both the final personal return and all FIT-161 fiduciary returns) to be filed and paid in full.

Inherited IRA and Retirement Accounts: Taxable When Withdrawn

When a surviving spouse inherits an IRA or 401(k), the account balance itself is not immediately taxable. But withdrawals from the inherited account are taxed as ordinary income in the year taken. The surviving spouse has more favorable rollover options than other beneficiaries: a surviving spouse can roll the inherited IRA into their own IRA and defer required minimum distributions until their own age-73 RMD date.

For inherited accounts that do not qualify for a spousal rollover — for example, when the beneficiary is an adult child rather than a spouse — the 10-year rule generally applies under federal law, requiring full distribution within 10 years of the original owner's death. Those distributions are all ordinary income to the beneficiary.

The Emergency Personnel Survivors Benefit: Tax Status

The $80,000 Emergency Personnel Survivors Benefit paid to survivors of Vermont firefighters and law enforcement officers killed in the line of duty is generally not subject to Vermont income tax. Under federal law, amounts received under public safety officer death benefit programs are excluded from gross income (IRC § 104), and Vermont generally conforms to this exclusion. Surviving families should confirm this with a tax professional when filing, as the specific facts can matter.

State and Local Government Employee Benefits: The W-4VT

Any pension or retirement benefit from a Vermont public entity — VSERS, VSTRS, VMERS, or a municipal plan — is taxable Vermont income. The paying entity will withhold Vermont income tax if the beneficiary files a W-4VT specifying withholding preferences. Get this form submitted to the Retirement Office promptly to avoid large underpayment bills at tax time.

Vermont's survivor benefit tax landscape is not complicated once you know the rules, but getting surprised by a large tax bill a year after a death compounds an already difficult situation. The Vermont Survivor Benefits Navigator includes a tax treatment summary for each major benefit type, a checklist for tax filings required during estate administration, and guidance on the E-2A tax clearance process that closes the loop on Vermont estate taxes.

See more Vermont guides →