Vermont Will Validity Requirements and How to Contest a Will

A will does not automatically become legally binding in Vermont just because someone signed it. The document must satisfy specific statutory requirements before the Probate Division will admit it to probate. And if the will does not meet those requirements — or if there are legitimate grounds to challenge its validity — Vermont law provides a formal process to contest it.

Whether you are an executor trying to admit a will or a beneficiary who believes the document is fraudulent or improperly executed, here is what Vermont law actually requires.

Vermont Will Validity Requirements

Under Vermont law, a valid will must meet these conditions:

1. Testator capacity. The person making the will (the testator) must be at least 18 years old and of sound mind at the time of signing. "Sound mind" means the testator understood the nature of the will, knew what property they owned, recognized who their natural heirs were, and understood that they were making a permanent legal document disposing of their assets.

2. Written document. Vermont requires a will to be in writing. Oral (spoken) wills are not recognized.

3. Signature. The testator must sign the will at the end of the document, or direct another person to sign it in their presence if they are physically incapable of signing.

4. Two witnesses. The will must be signed in the presence of at least two adult witnesses who are present at the same time. Each witness must sign the will in the testator's presence and in each other's presence.

Interested witnesses: Vermont does not automatically invalidate a will because a witness is also a beneficiary, but it raises questions about undue influence. Best practice is to use disinterested witnesses — people who inherit nothing under the will.

Holographic Wills in Vermont

Vermont does not recognize holographic wills. A holographic will is a handwritten, unwitnessed document — a category recognized by many states but not Vermont.

If a Vermont resident writes out their wishes by hand, signs it, but has no witnesses, that document is not a valid will under Vermont law. The estate would proceed as if the person died intestate (without a will), with assets distributed according to Vermont's intestate succession statutes.

This is a trap that catches people who handwrite "just in case" documents without understanding Vermont's requirements. If a decedent left behind a handwritten, unwitnessed document expressing their wishes, consult a Vermont probate attorney before assuming the document is legally binding.

Self-Proving Wills in Vermont

A self-proving will includes an affidavit signed by the witnesses and notarized at the time of execution. The affidavit states that the witnesses saw the testator sign and that the testator appeared to be of sound mind.

The benefit: when a self-proving will is submitted to the Vermont Probate Division, the witnesses do not need to appear in court or provide sworn statements to prove the will's execution. The affidavit serves as their testimony.

A self-proving affidavit does not make the will more valid — it simply makes it easier to admit to probate. For wills signed years ago, where witnesses may be deceased or difficult to locate, the self-proving affidavit eliminates a significant procedural obstacle.

Vermont courts regularly see wills submitted without self-proving affidavits. In those cases, the court may require a witness to appear and testify, or may accept alternate evidence of proper execution if witnesses cannot be located.

Grounds for Contesting a Will in Vermont

Contesting a will is a formal legal proceeding. You cannot simply object verbally at the courthouse — you must file written grounds for your challenge, and they must be legally recognized.

Vermont courts recognize these grounds for a will contest:

Lack of testamentary capacity. The testator lacked the mental capacity to make a will at the time of signing. This might apply if the testator had advanced dementia, was under the influence of medication that impaired judgment, or was otherwise incapable of understanding the nature of the document.

Evidence used in capacity challenges includes: medical records from the period surrounding the will's execution, testimony from caregivers or healthcare providers, prior diagnoses of cognitive impairment, and statements from individuals who interacted with the testator near the time of signing.

Undue influence. Someone exerted improper pressure on the testator, overcoming their free will and causing them to make a will they would not otherwise have made. This is the most common will contest ground and the hardest to prove.

Red flags for undue influence: the testator was isolated from family by a particular person, the will dramatically departs from earlier wills or stated wishes, the beneficiary was present during the drafting and execution, or the testator was particularly vulnerable due to illness or dependency.

Fraud or forgery. The will is a fabrication, the testator's signature is forged, or the testator was deceived about what they were signing.

Improper execution. The will does not meet Vermont's formal requirements — fewer than two witnesses, witnesses not present simultaneously, or the signature absent or improperly placed.

Revocation. The will was validly revoked before the testator's death by a subsequent will, a formal written revocation, or by physical act (burning, tearing, or destroying the will with the intent to revoke it).

How to File a Will Contest in Vermont

Timing matters significantly. If you believe a will is invalid, you must act before the Probate Division admits the will and issues Letters Testamentary. Once the will is admitted, contesting it becomes substantially more difficult and requires different procedural steps.

The process:

1. File written objections to the allowance of the will with the Vermont Superior Court Probate Division in the county where the estate is being administered.
2. State specific, legally recognized grounds — not just that you are unhappy with the distribution.
3. The court will schedule a hearing. You must appear and present evidence supporting your grounds.
4. In an ancillary probate scenario (where the decedent did not live in Vermont), written objections must be filed at least 14 business days before the scheduled Vermont hearing date.

Vermont does not have a fixed deadline expressed in days after death — the window is tied to the probate court's admission of the will. Once admitted without objection, the will stands unless challenged through a separate litigation proceeding, which is far more costly and difficult.

Practical Considerations

Contesting a will in Vermont is expensive, emotionally exhausting, and statistically difficult to win. Courts are reluctant to override a person's expressed wishes without compelling evidence. You will need a Vermont probate attorney and should expect the process to take a year or more if litigated.

Before committing to a contest, honestly assess the evidence you have. Disagreeing with the distribution is not grounds for a contest. Suspecting but not proving undue influence is not enough. The legal standard requires evidence that rises above suspicion to provable facts.

If family dynamics suggest a will contest is possible, the executor should anticipate this during administration. Delay in distributing assets until the objection period closes protects the executor from personal liability if a successful challenge later requires assets to be returned.

The Vermont Probate Process Guide covers how the will admission process works in Vermont probate court, what happens if no will is found, and the executor's duties when a will contest is filed after administration begins.

See more Vermont guides →