Alternatives to the ACT Public Trustee for Estate Administration

If you are considering handing an ACT estate to the Public Trustee and Guardian because the process feels overwhelming, the most important thing to know before you decide is the cost: 4.4% capital commission on the first $300,000 of estate value, 3.3% on the next $300,000, 2.2% on the next $300,000, and 1.1% on the balance — plus 6.6% on all estate income. On a typical Canberra estate valued at $600,000, that is $23,100 in commission alone, before disbursements. There are three alternatives that cost a fraction of that amount and keep the executor in control of the process.

The Three Alternatives Compared

All three alternatives avoid the PTG's percentage-based commission structure entirely.

Option 1: Self-Administration With an ACT-Specific Guide

The most cost-effective alternative. You do the work yourself using a structured guide that covers every step specific to the ACT — the online probate notice system, Forms 3.1 and 3.11, bank thresholds, property transfer, tax obligations, and the six-month distribution timeline.

What you need to know. Self-administration in the ACT is more viable than most executors expect because the core process is administrative, not adversarial. You are completing forms, publishing notices, contacting banks, lodging property transfers, and filing tax returns. The ACT Supreme Court accepts applications from self-represented executors and holds them to the same standards as solicitors — which means the process is identical whether you hire someone or not. The difference is whether you know the requirements in advance or discover them through requisitions.

The key risks. The probate notice timing window (14 days to 3 months before filing — miss it and you republish from scratch), the common form errors that trigger requisitions (staple removal, nett vs gross values, name discrepancies), and the six-month Family Provision Act window that must elapse before final distribution.

The When Someone Dies in ACT — Estate Settlement Guide covers all of this across 16 chapters with standalone worksheets. The free First 48 Hours Checklist is available separately to assess whether the approach fits your situation.

Option 2: Private Solicitor (Full Service)

A Canberra estate solicitor handles the entire process: forms, court filings, bank correspondence, property transfer, and tax returns. You provide documents and signatures; they manage everything else.

What it costs. Standard probate representation starts at $3,000 to $5,000 for obtaining the Grant of Probate. Full estate administration — including property transfer, bank closures, tax returns, and final distribution — typically runs $8,000 to $15,000. Hourly rates for Canberra estate solicitors range from $350 to $500. Some firms offer fixed-fee packages for the court application, but full administration is usually billed hourly.

When this is the right choice. Contested estates where a family provision claim is likely, complex trust structures, corporate assets, or insolvent estates where creditor priority order matters. Also appropriate when the executor genuinely does not have the time or cognitive capacity to manage the process during grief.

The cost comparison. Even at the high end ($15,000), a private solicitor costs less than the PTG commission on estates above roughly $350,000. On a $600,000 estate, the solicitor saves $8,100 or more compared to the PTG. However, a solicitor also costs 10-50 times more than the self-administration approach.

Option 3: Hybrid (Guide + Solicitor Review)

The middle ground. You do the work using a guide, then pay a solicitor to review your completed forms before filing. This gives you the cost savings of self-administration with the error-checking safety net of professional review.

What it costs. The guide at plus $500 to $800 for a solicitor to review Forms 3.1 and 3.11 before you file. Total: under $1,000 in most cases.

How it works. You complete the probate notice publication, prepare both forms using the guide's line-by-line walkthrough, compile the supporting documents, and then book a single consultation with a Canberra estate solicitor to review the package before filing. The solicitor flags any issues you may have missed. You correct them and file the application yourself.

When this makes sense. Estates over $500,000 where the filing fee and stakes justify the additional $500-$800 investment. Risk-averse executors who want professional confirmation before submitting to the court. Executors who are generally capable but lack confidence on one or two specific steps.

Why Executors Default to the PTG

The ACT Public Trustee and Guardian positions itself as the safe, professional option for overwhelmed executors. Their marketing emphasises reliability and expertise, and their information pages are designed to encourage families to renounce executorship and hand everything over. The reasons families default to the PTG:

Grief and cognitive overload. In the weeks after a death, the idea of handing everything to a professional has powerful emotional appeal. The PTG offers relief from decision-making at the time when decision-making feels impossible.

Fear of personal liability. Executors worry that making a mistake will leave them personally liable. While personal liability is real in specific circumstances (distributing before the six-month window closes, breaching fiduciary duty), the vast majority of executor liability arises from inaction or ignorance, not from attempting the process.

No awareness of alternatives. Many families do not realise that self-administration is a viable option, or that a solicitor charges a flat or hourly fee rather than a percentage commission. The PTG's commission structure only becomes shocking when compared to the alternatives.

The irony: the PTG's commission structure means that the more valuable the estate, the more expensive their services become — precisely the estates where professional fees are least justified as a percentage of value.

Who This Is For

• Executors who have been told to use the Public Trustee but want to understand the cost implications before deciding
• Families who want to keep estate administration private and avoid the PTG's standardised process
• Anyone who has looked at the PTG's fee schedule and calculated that $23,100 on a $600,000 estate is more than they are willing to pay
• Executors who want to preserve estate value for beneficiaries rather than lose a significant percentage to administration fees
• Families who assumed the PTG was the only option and want to know what else is available

Who This Is NOT For

• Estates where no family member is willing or able to serve as executor — the PTG exists for exactly this situation
• Deceased persons who named the PTG as executor in their will — the appointment is binding unless a court orders otherwise
• Estates involving a person under a guardianship order where the PTG has been appointed as administrator
• Families where inter-beneficiary conflict is so severe that a neutral third party is the only way to prevent litigation

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I change my mind after engaging the PTG?

Once you renounce executorship in favour of the PTG, reversing the decision is extremely difficult and typically requires a court application. It is worth exploring alternatives thoroughly before renouncing.

Is the PTG's 4.4% commission negotiable?

The commission rates are set by statute and are not negotiable. The PTG applies the same scale to all estates regardless of complexity.

What if I start self-administering and then get stuck?

You can engage a solicitor at any point for specific steps without handing the entire estate to the PTG. Many Canberra firms offer unbundled services — you pay for the specific help you need rather than full representation.

Is the PTG slower than self-administration?

The PTG manages many estates simultaneously and operates on institutional timelines. Self-administration moves at your pace, constrained only by statutory waiting periods (14-day probate notice, six-month Family Provision window) and court processing times. In practice, motivated self-administrators often complete the process faster than the PTG.

Does the PTG provide better legal protection for the executor?

When the PTG administers an estate, there is no personal executor to be liable — the PTG assumes that role. However, for straightforward estates, the liability risk is manageable with proper guidance. The most common liability trigger (distributing before the six-month window) is a timing issue, not a legal complexity issue. A guide that maps this timeline eliminates the primary risk.

See more Australian Capital Territory guides →