Indiana Advance Directive Kit vs Free Hospital Form: Which One Actually Works?

If you're deciding between the free Indiana advance directive PDF from your hospital and a paid execution kit, here's the short answer: the free form gives you the blanks to fill in, but it does not tell you how to fill them in correctly under Indiana law. A complete kit covers the witness eligibility rules, remote signing procedures under SEA 204, and POST/DNR coordination that the hospital PDF leaves out entirely. The free form is a starting point — the kit is the execution system.

What the Free Hospital Form Actually Includes

Indiana hospitals — IU Health, Franciscan Health, Community Health Network — each offer their own version of the advance directive PDF. Since Senate Enrolled Act 204 consolidated Indiana's three separate documents (healthcare power of attorney, healthcare representative appointment, and living will declaration) into a single form, most hospital PDFs now include all three sections on one document.

The free form typically includes:

• Blank fields for your Healthcare Representative designation
• A living will declaration section with checkboxes for treatment preferences
• Signature lines for you and your witnesses
• Basic instructions ("sign in front of two witnesses")

That is the entire package. No instructions on witness eligibility. No explanation of the dual witness standard. No mention of remote execution. No guidance on POST or DNR coordination.

Where the Free Form Creates Problems

The Dual Witness Trap

Indiana law applies two different witness standards within the same document. Your Healthcare Representative section requires two adult witnesses with moderate restrictions — they cannot be your healthcare provider or an employee of your healthcare provider. Your Living Will Declaration section enforces far stricter exclusions: no parent, spouse, child, grandchild, heir, named HCR, or anyone financially responsible for your care.

The free form has one signature block for witnesses at the bottom. Nothing on the form distinguishes between the two standards. Families routinely bring a spouse or adult child to witness the entire document and discover — sometimes at the ICU — that the living will section is invalid.

No Remote Execution Guidance

SEA 204 introduced the ability to sign an advance directive electronically over live video with a notary or two witnesses. Paper counterparts must be assembled into a single file within 10 business days. No hospital PDF mentions this option or explains the procedural requirements.

No Clinical Order Coordination

An advance directive is a legal planning document. EMTs are not required to find it or follow it during an emergency. A POST (Physician Orders for Scope of Treatment) form is a clinical order your physician signs — EMTs must follow it immediately. The free form does not explain the difference, when you need both, or how to initiate the POST conversation with your doctor.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Who Should Use the Free Form Alone

The free hospital PDF is sufficient if all of the following are true:

• You have a straightforward family situation (married, adult children, no blended families)
• You already understand which witnesses qualify for the living will section
• You do not need remote signing
• You already have POST/DNR orders through your physician
• You do not own real estate or have Medicaid planning concerns
• You are comfortable reading Indiana Code Title 16, Article 36 yourself

If that describes you, download the form and sign it. A valid advance directive — even an imperfect one — is better than no directive at all.

Who Needs the Complete Kit

• Adult children helping an aging parent. You need to screen witnesses correctly the first time. Bringing the wrong family member to the signing — a common mistake — invalidates the living will section and you may not discover the problem until a medical crisis.
• Anyone facing surgery. Pre-admission paperwork asks about advance directives on a deadline. You need a valid directive completed before your procedure, not a template that requires you to research witness rules independently.
• Unmarried partners. Indiana's default hierarchy puts your partner's parents and siblings ahead of you for medical decisions. The kit explains exactly how to designate your partner as HCR and ensure the designation holds.
• Homeowners with Medicaid concerns. If you or your parent might need Medicaid-funded long-term care, a TOD deed alone does not protect the home. Indiana's FSSA can pursue recovery claims against TOD transfers, joint accounts, and revocable trusts under the expanded 9-month filing window.

Who This Is NOT For

• People who already have an attorney-drafted advance directive and estate plan
• Anyone working with a hospice team that provides directive assistance as part of their services
• Residents of other states (Indiana law has jurisdiction-specific requirements that do not transfer)

The Real Risk of the Free Form

The form itself is legally valid. Indiana law does not require you to use a specific template. The risk is not the document — it is the execution. A correctly signed form with the wrong witnesses is void. A properly witnessed form without POST coordination may not be followed in an emergency. A valid directive without Medicaid planning can leave the family home exposed to recovery claims.

The free form costs nothing. The Indiana Advance Directive & Living Will Kit costs — less than one hour of an elder law attorney's time — and includes the 18-chapter guide, dual witness checklists, remote execution checklist, POST/DNR coordination guide, TOD deed execution guide, and Medicaid recovery protection guide as 7 printable PDFs.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the free hospital advance directive form legally valid in Indiana?

Yes. Indiana law does not require a specific form — any document that meets the requirements of Indiana Code 16-36-4 (for living wills) and 16-36-1 (for healthcare representative appointments) is valid. The issue is not the form's legality but whether you execute it correctly, particularly the witness requirements for the living will section.

Can I use the free form and just look up the witness rules myself?

You can. The relevant statutes are IC 16-36-4-8 (living will witnesses) and IC 16-36-1-7 (HCR witnesses). The challenge is that the two standards are in different code sections, and the living will exclusions are significantly stricter than most people expect. The kit puts both checklists side by side so you can screen witnesses once.

What happens if my advance directive has the wrong witnesses?

If a living will is witnessed by someone excluded under IC 16-36-4-8 — such as a spouse, child, parent, heir, or the named healthcare representative — the living will declaration section is voidable. Your Healthcare Representative designation may still be valid if those witnesses meet the less restrictive standard. The result is a partially valid document that may not express your wishes when needed.

Does the kit include the actual advance directive form?

The kit is an execution system — it guides you through completing the form correctly, not a replacement for the form itself. Indiana's statutory form is freely available from hospitals and the Indiana State Department of Health. The kit's value is the 18-chapter guide, witness checklists, and coordination documents that the form does not include.

How much does an elder law attorney charge to prepare an advance directive in Indiana?

Indianapolis-area elder law attorneys typically charge $200–$400 per hour, with a comprehensive advance directive and estate planning package running $1,500 or more. Indiana law explicitly allows you to execute your own advance directive without an attorney. The kit provides the procedural guidance to do it correctly at a fraction of the cost.

See more Indiana guides →