Prior Rights and Legal Rights (Legitim) Scotland: A Plain-English Guide

Scotland does not allow complete testamentary freedom. Regardless of what a Will says — or whether there is a Will at all — certain close relatives have automatic financial claims against the estate that cannot be overridden by any testamentary provision. These protections come in two tiers: Prior Rights and Legal Rights.

Understanding how these work is essential for any Scottish executor, because they must be calculated and offered to beneficiaries before the estate can be distributed.

The Sequence Matters

Prior Rights and Legal Rights do not operate simultaneously. They must be applied in a specific order, and each one reduces the pot of money available for the next.

1. Prior Rights are satisfied first — these are the surviving spouse's statutory entitlements to the family home, furniture, and a cash sum
2. Legal Rights (Legitim) apply to whatever remains of the moveable estate after Prior Rights are exhausted
3. The Free Estate — what is left after Prior Rights and Legal Rights — is then distributed according to the Will or, if there is none, the intestacy hierarchy

Prior Rights: The Surviving Spouse's Priority Claims

Prior Rights are automatic statutory entitlements that belong exclusively to the surviving spouse or civil partner. They apply on intestacy (no Will). They take effect before any other claim on the estate.

Prior Rights have three components, with current 2026 limits:

1. The Dwelling House Right

The surviving spouse is entitled to the deceased's interest in the dwellinghouse in which the spouse was ordinarily resident at the date of death — up to a value of £473,000. If the house is worth less than this, the spouse gets it outright. If it is worth more, the spouse receives a cash sum of £473,000 instead.

2. The Furniture and Plenishings Right

The surviving spouse is entitled to the furniture and household contents of that dwellinghouse — up to a value of £29,000.

3. The Financial Provision (Cash Sum)

The surviving spouse is entitled to a cash sum from the estate:

• £50,000 if the deceased left surviving children (or other descendants)
• £89,000 if the deceased left no surviving children

These figures are periodically updated by statutory instrument. Always verify the current limits before calculating.

An important point: Prior Rights come out of both heritable and moveable estate. The dwelling house right is taken from the heritable estate; the furniture and cash provision are taken from the moveable estate.

Legal Rights: What Spouses and Children Are Always Entitled To

Legal Rights — historically called Legitim for children's claims and jus relictae (spouse's right) or jus relicti (widower's right) — are the second tier. Unlike Prior Rights, Legal Rights:

• Apply to moveable estate only — never heritable property
• Apply whether or not there is a Will
• Cannot be removed by the terms of any Will

The calculation is based on the net moveable estate: moveable assets minus moveable debts.

Where both a spouse and children survive:

• The surviving spouse is entitled to one-third of the net moveable estate
• The children together are entitled to one-third of the net moveable estate
• The remaining third forms part of the Free Estate and follows the Will or intestacy rules

Where only a spouse survives (no children):

• The surviving spouse is entitled to one-half of the net moveable estate

Where only children survive (no spouse):

• The children together are entitled to one-half of the net moveable estate

Children's Legal Rights are divided equally among them. If a child has died before the parent, that child's share passes to their own children (the grandchildren of the deceased).

The Election: Legal Rights or Legacy — Not Both

Here is the constraint that catches many beneficiaries off guard.

If the deceased left a Will, a beneficiary who has a Legal Rights claim must choose one of two options:

Option A: Accept the legacy left to them under the Will and waive their Legal Rights claim.

Option B: Claim their Legal Rights entitlement and give up the legacy under the Will.

They cannot do both. Scots law does not allow double-dipping.

This election matters most when the Will leaves a specific legacy that might be worth more or less than the Legal Rights calculation. A spouse left the entire estate under the Will might actually receive more by accepting the legacy than by claiming Legal Rights — especially if the estate is predominantly heritable property (since Legal Rights only apply to moveable estate). Conversely, if the Will leaves a child a small specific bequest and the child's Legal Rights fraction is larger, claiming Legal Rights is financially advantageous.

Executors must calculate both options and present them to each entitled beneficiary. The election must be documented formally in writing.

A Practical Example

Assume an intestate estate with a surviving spouse and two adult children. The estate consists of:

• House: £400,000 (heritable)
• Bank accounts: £80,000 (moveable)
• Credit card debt: £5,000 (moveable liability)

Step 1: Prior Rights

Dwelling House Right: spouse takes the house (value £400,000, within the £473,000 limit). Furniture: assume £15,000 (within £29,000 limit). Cash provision: £50,000 (children survive).

Heritable estate after Prior Rights: £0 (house taken by spouse) Moveable estate after Prior Rights: £80,000 - £15,000 furniture - £50,000 cash = £15,000 remaining

Step 2: Legal Rights

Net moveable estate remaining: £15,000 - £5,000 debt = £10,000

Spouse's Legal Rights: one-third = £3,333 Children's Legal Rights (total): one-third = £3,333 (split equally, so £1,667 each) Free Estate moveable: £3,334 (distributed per intestacy hierarchy)

In this example, the surviving spouse has done very well through Prior Rights (the house, furniture, cash). The Legal Rights calculation on the remaining moveable estate is modest by comparison.

Legal Rights in a Testate Estate (Where There Is a Will)

Legal Rights operate as a debt on the estate even when there is a Will. If the Will attempts to disinherit a child or leaves a surviving spouse with nothing, the disinherited party can still claim their Legal Rights fraction from the net moveable estate. The executor must offer this calculation regardless of what the Will says.

The executor cannot simply distribute the estate per the Will and ignore Legal Rights. Doing so exposes the executor to personal liability if a Legal Rights claim is later pursued.

Prior Rights and Legal Rights are among the most complex and distinctively Scottish aspects of estate administration. The When Someone Dies in Scotland Estate Settlement Guide includes a dedicated intestacy section with calculation templates that walk you through Prior Rights and Legitim step by step for common family scenarios.

See more Scotland guides →