How to Nominate a Guardian for Minor Children in Maine

If you have children under 18, the guardian nomination in your will is arguably the most important provision in your entire estate plan. Everything else — asset distribution, probate avoidance, tax planning — is about money. This is about who raises your kids.

How Guardian Nomination Works in Maine

Under the Maine Uniform Probate Code (Title 18-C), a parent can nominate a guardian for their minor children in a will or in a separate written document. The nomination isn't automatically binding — the probate court makes the final appointment and must determine that the nomination serves the child's best interests — but a clearly stated parental preference carries enormous weight.

If both parents die or are incapacitated, the court looks to the most recent nominations. If both parents nominated the same person, that's typically who gets appointed. If they nominated different people, the court decides based on the child's best interests.

What Happens Without a Nomination

If both parents die without naming a guardian, the probate court selects one. The court considers family members first — grandparents, aunts, uncles — but it's making this decision with limited information about your preferences, your family dynamics, and your children's relationships.

This process takes time. While the court proceedings play out, your children may be placed in temporary foster care or with a family member you might not have chosen. The legal proceedings create stress, delay, and cost — all during the worst moment of your children's lives.

Choosing the Right Guardian

Beyond the obvious qualities (trustworthy, responsible, loves your children), consider:

Parenting philosophy. Do they share your views on education, discipline, religion, and lifestyle? A detailed parenting letter (not a legal document, but a guide for the guardian) can communicate your wishes.

Practical capacity. Can they realistically absorb additional children into their household? Consider their age, health, financial stability, housing situation, and existing family responsibilities.

Location. Will your children need to relocate? Change schools? Leave their community? This is a significant disruption on top of losing parents.

Relationship with the other parent's family. If the guardian you choose has conflicts with your co-parent's relatives, it can create ongoing tension that affects the children.

Age and longevity. A grandparent who is 70 when your child is 5 may not realistically be able to serve for the 13 years until the child reaches 18. Name a younger alternate.

Separating Guardianship from Money Management

You can nominate different people for personal guardianship (raising the children) and financial management (handling the inheritance). This is common when your best choice for raising your children isn't your best choice for managing a significant sum of money.

Options:

• Name one person as guardian of the person and a different person (or a professional trustee) as guardian of the estate
• Create a trust for the children's inheritance with an independent trustee, and name the guardian as someone who can request distributions for the children's needs

This prevents situations where the guardian is managing hundreds of thousands of dollars without financial expertise or oversight.

Practical Steps

1. Talk to your nominee first. Don't name someone as guardian without discussing it. They need to understand the commitment and agree to serve.
2. Name alternates. Your first choice may be unable or unwilling to serve when the time comes.
3. Include the nomination in your will with the full legal name and relationship of the nominee.
4. Write a parenting letter. Cover education preferences, medical history, religious practices, family traditions, and anything else the guardian should know.
5. Review annually. Relationships change, circumstances change, children's needs change.

The Maine Basic Estate Planning Kit includes a guardian nomination worksheet and parenting letter template to ensure your wishes are clearly documented alongside your will.

See more Maine guides →