Joint Tenancy vs. Tenancy in Common in Maine

How your property is titled in Maine determines whether it passes through probate or bypasses it entirely, whether your share can be inherited by your chosen beneficiaries or is locked to a co-owner, and whether creditors can reach it. This isn't abstract legal theory — it's the single most consequential detail in many Maine estate plans.

Maine Is a Common-Law Property State

First, the baseline: Maine does not have community property rules. Unlike Arizona, California, or Texas, marriage in Maine does not automatically create shared ownership of assets. Property belongs to whoever holds the title. If you buy a home and only your name is on the deed, it's your separate property — your spouse has no ownership interest (though they may have a claim through the elective share after your death).

This makes how you title property a deliberate estate planning decision, not an automatic one.

Joint Tenancy with Right of Survivorship

When two or more people hold property as joint tenants with right of survivorship, each person owns an undivided interest in the entire property. When one owner dies, their share automatically passes to the surviving owner(s) — no probate, no will needed.

Advantages:

• Immediate, automatic transfer at death
• Avoids probate completely
• Simple to create (the survivorship language goes in the deed)

Risks:

• Adding a child as joint tenant is a gift of 50% of the property's value — potentially triggering gift tax reporting
• The child's share is immediately exposed to their creditors, lawsuits, bankruptcy, or divorce
• If the child dies first, you're back to sole ownership and need a new plan
• It only delays probate — when the last surviving tenant dies, the property enters their estate
• You can't leave your share to anyone else by will

Tenancy in Common

Each co-owner holds a distinct, divisible share (which may be equal or unequal). There's no right of survivorship. When one owner dies, their share passes through their probate estate — to whoever the will names, or through intestacy if there's no will.

Advantages:

• Each owner controls what happens to their share after death
• Shares can be unequal (one person can own 70%, another 30%)
• Each owner can sell, mortgage, or transfer their share independently

Risks:

• The deceased owner's share goes through probate
• Any co-owner can force a partition sale (a court-ordered sale if they want out and the others don't)
• No automatic transfer at death — heirs must go through probate or rely on a will

Which to Use in Your Estate Plan

Married couples (primary home): Joint tenancy with right of survivorship is the most common choice. The surviving spouse automatically gets the house, no probate needed. Just make sure the deed explicitly says "joint tenants with right of survivorship" — in Maine, a deed to two people that doesn't specify creates a tenancy in common by default.

Blended families: Tenancy in common is usually better. If you own 50% and want your share to go to your children (not your current spouse's children), tenancy in common lets you control distribution through your will. Joint tenancy would pass your share to the surviving co-owner automatically, potentially disinheriting your children.

Parent and adult child: Joint tenancy is risky. You expose the property to the child's creditors and create a completed gift. A Transfer on Death Deed achieves the same probate-avoidance result without any current transfer or creditor exposure.

Multiple siblings inheriting together: Tenancy in common with a clear agreement about usage, expenses, and buyout rights. Without this, any sibling can force a partition sale — a common outcome for inherited Maine camp properties.

The Transfer on Death Deed Alternative

For many situations, a TODD is a better option than either form of co-ownership. You keep sole ownership and full control during your lifetime. At death, the property transfers to named beneficiaries outside probate. No gift, no creditor exposure, no loss of control. Recording costs $40 at most county registries.

The Maine Basic Estate Planning Kit includes a property titling analysis worksheet that walks you through each property you own and recommends the optimal titling and transfer mechanism for your specific situation.

See more Maine guides →