New York Elective Share: EPTL 5-1.1-A Explained

You cannot fully disinherit your spouse in New York. Under Estates, Powers and Trusts Law § 5-1.1-A, a surviving spouse has the statutory right to claim the greater of $50,000 or one-third of the decedent's "net estate" — regardless of what the will says. This is the elective share, and it's one of the most consequential provisions in New York estate planning.

What the Surviving Spouse Gets

The elective share is calculated as the greater of:

• $50,000, or
• One-third of the net estate

The net estate isn't just probate assets. EPTL § 5-1.1-A includes a broad category of "testamentary substitutes" — assets the decedent transferred during life but retained effective control over. This prevents strategic pre-death asset shifting designed to leave the spouse with nothing.

What Counts as the "Net Estate"

The net estate starts with probate assets (everything passing under the will or by intestacy) and adds testamentary substitutes, which include:

• Revocable trusts — assets in a trust the decedent could have revoked or amended
• Joint bank accounts — the decedent's proportional contribution
• Totten trust accounts (in-trust-for bank accounts)
• Gifts made within one year of death exceeding the annual exclusion
• Property over which the decedent held a general power of appointment
• Retirement accounts and life insurance payable to someone other than the estate, if the decedent retained the right to change beneficiaries

The net estate is then reduced by debts, funeral expenses, and estate administration costs.

The testamentary substitute rules mean that simply moving assets into a revocable trust, retitling accounts as joint with a child, or changing life insurance beneficiaries doesn't defeat the elective share. The calculation reaches back and captures these transfers.

How to Claim the Elective Share

The right of election is personal to the surviving spouse. It must be affirmatively exercised by filing a notice of election in the Surrogate's Court where the estate is being administered. The filing deadline is the later of:

• Six months after Letters Testamentary or Letters of Administration are issued, or
• Two years from the date of death

Extensions may be granted by the court for good cause. If the surviving spouse fails to file within the deadline, the right is permanently waived and the will's terms control distribution.

A guardian or agent under a power of attorney can exercise the right of election on behalf of an incapacitated spouse, but only with prior court approval from the Surrogate's Court.

When the Elective Share Doesn't Apply

The surviving spouse loses the right of election if they:

• Executed a valid waiver — a written, notarized document voluntarily giving up the right (common in prenuptial and postnuptial agreements)
• Abandoned the decedent — legally abandoned the marriage without justification
• Were disqualified under EPTL § 5-1.2 — specific grounds including abandonment, failure to support, or procurement of a divorce or annulment

Separation alone does not forfeit the right. Unless a final divorce decree has been entered, a legally separated spouse retains the right of election.

Planning Around the Elective Share

For estate plans that need to balance multiple beneficiaries — particularly in blended families — the elective share creates constraints:

You can't cut your spouse below one-third. Any plan that gives the surviving spouse less than one-third of the net estate (including testamentary substitutes) is vulnerable to an election that forces redistribution.

The one-third is a floor, not a ceiling. You can leave your spouse more than one-third. The elective share only matters when the will provides less.

Credit Shelter Trusts must be structured carefully. A Bypass Trust funded at the first spouse's death doesn't qualify as property passing to the surviving spouse unless the trust gives the spouse specific rights (such as all income and a limited power of appointment). If the trust terms are too restrictive, the surviving spouse may elect against it.

Life insurance and retirement accounts are caught. If you name your children as life insurance beneficiaries to the exclusion of your spouse, those proceeds get added to the net estate calculation. Your spouse can effectively claim one-third of those benefits.

The Elective Share vs. Intestacy

If the decedent dies without a will, the surviving spouse inherits under EPTL § 4-1.1 — the first $50,000 plus half the remaining estate. Whether intestacy or the elective share is more favorable depends on the estate size and number of beneficiaries.

For estates under $150,000 with children, intestacy often provides more than the elective share. For larger estates with multiple children, the elective share's one-third may exceed the intestacy share. The surviving spouse can choose whichever is greater — they're not limited to one statute.

The New York Basic Estate Planning Kit walks through the elective share calculation step by step and includes asset inventory worksheets that capture both probate assets and testamentary substitutes — so you can plan with full awareness of what your spouse is legally entitled to.

See more New York guides →