Is Five Wishes Valid in Texas? What You Need to Know
Is Five Wishes Valid in Texas? What You Need to Know
Five Wishes is a nationally distributed advance directive created by Aging with Dignity. It's popular because it's written in plain language and covers emotional and spiritual preferences alongside medical decisions. But the question Texas residents actually need answered is: will a hospital honor it?
The Short Answer
Five Wishes meets the legal requirements for an advance directive in Texas, provided it's properly witnessed or notarized according to Texas execution rules (two qualified witnesses with at least one fully disinterested, or a notary public acknowledgment).
Under Health and Safety Code § 166.005, Texas recognizes advance directives that comply with the laws of the state where they were executed. Since Five Wishes is designed to meet the requirements of all 50 states, a properly executed copy is technically valid.
The Practical Problem
Legal validity and hospital acceptance are different things. Texas hospital legal departments and clinical staff are trained to recognize the layout of the state's four statutory forms — the Directive to Physicians, Medical Power of Attorney, OOH-DNR, and Declaration for Mental Health Treatment.
Five Wishes doesn't look like any of these. When an unfamiliar document arrives at a hospital intake desk during an emergency, common outcomes include:
- Internal legal review that can take days or weeks
- Requests for additional documentation to confirm the agent's authority
- Delays in honoring the directive while staff verify its validity under Texas law
These delays aren't malicious — they're the result of staff following their training, which centers on recognizing the standard Texas forms.
What Five Wishes Covers vs. What Texas Requires
| Feature | Five Wishes | Texas Statutory Forms |
|---|---|---|
| Living will / treatment preferences | Yes (Wishes 1-2) | Directive to Physicians |
| Healthcare agent designation | Yes (Wish 1) | Medical Power of Attorney |
| Comfort and dignity preferences | Yes (Wishes 3-4) | Not a separate form |
| Spiritual/emotional wishes | Yes (Wish 5) | Not covered |
| Out-of-Hospital DNR | No | OOH-DNR (separate form) |
| Mental health treatment | No | DMHT (separate form) |
| Witness disqualification rules | General | Texas-specific statutory requirements |
The most significant gap: Five Wishes does not include an Out-of-Hospital DNR. If you want EMS personnel to withhold resuscitation outside a hospital, you need the Texas OOH-DNR form regardless of whether you have Five Wishes.
Five Wishes also doesn't address the Declaration for Mental Health Treatment, which covers psychoactive medications and convulsive therapy.
Free Download
Get the Texas — Advance Directive Quick-Start
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
When Five Wishes Works
Five Wishes is a good starting point for people who want a values-based conversation about end-of-life care. The emotional and spiritual sections (Wishes 3-5) capture preferences that Texas statutory forms don't address — things like whether you want to be at home, whether you want music playing, or how you want to be remembered.
These sections aren't legally enforceable, but they provide guidance for your healthcare agent and family.
The Recommended Approach
For Texas residents, the most reliable approach is to execute the Texas statutory forms as your primary legal documents and keep Five Wishes as a supplemental values guide. Your statutory forms get immediate hospital recognition; Five Wishes gives your agent context for decisions the forms don't cover.
The Texas Advance Directive & Living Will Kit provides all four Texas statutory forms with execution checklists, designed to work alongside any supplemental planning document you choose to use.
Get Your Free Texas — Advance Directive Quick-Start
Download the Texas — Advance Directive Quick-Start — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.