SA Advance Directive Kit vs Free Government ACD Form: Which One Do You Actually Need?
The Short Answer
The SA Health Advance Care Directive form is the correct statutory document — every completed ACD in South Australia uses it. A paid advance directive kit doesn't replace that form. It wraps it in the procedural guidance, clinical drafting tools, and witnessing checklists that the form itself doesn't include. If you're confident you can write clinically precise treatment refusals, coordinate multiple SDM acceptances in the correct signing order, and independently verify your witness isn't disqualified under the Advance Care Directives Act 2013, the free form is all you need. If any of those steps feel unclear, a structured kit closes those gaps.
What the Free Government Form Covers
SA Health and the Office of the Public Advocate provide the blank ACD form, an information sheet for witnesses, and basic instructions explaining what each section is for. These are the legally compliant templates — no paid product changes that. The form covers:
- Part 1: your personal details and who you are as the "appointer"
- Part 2: appointment of up to four Substitute Decision-Makers in sequential order
- Part 3: binding provisions (refusals of healthcare) and non-binding provisions (values and wishes)
- Part 4: signature, witness, and interpreter sections
The Public Advocate also publishes a separate guide explaining the general purpose of an ACD, why you should have one, and what the legal definitions mean.
What the Free Form Doesn't Cover
The form assumes you already know how to complete it correctly. That's where most failures happen — not because families choose the wrong document, but because they fill it in ways that weaken its legal force.
| Factor | Free SA Health ACD Form | Paid Advance Directive Kit |
|---|---|---|
| Statutory compliance | Yes — this is the official form | Uses the same official form |
| Clinical drafting guidance | None — blank fields only | Treatment Decision Worksheet with pre-drafted refusal wording for CPR, ventilation, nutrition, dialysis |
| Signing sequence instructions | Brief note that SDMs sign first | Step-by-step Signing and Witnessing Checklist with room-ready sequence |
| Witness verification | Lists authorised witness classes | Conflict-of-Interest Witness Verification Checklist with disqualifier screening |
| SDM coordination | Names the role | SDM Appointment Worksheet covering limits, sequential ordering, acceptance tracking |
| Storage and distribution | Mentions My Health Record | Document Distribution Log with 5 certified copies, GP, hospital, SDMs |
| EPA coordination | Not mentioned | EPA Coordination Worksheet cross-checking coverage gaps with the Powers of Attorney and Agency Act 1984 |
| Post-death estate transition | Not covered | Post-Death Estate Transition Timeline covering the $15,000 direct bank release under Section 100 of the Succession Act 2023 |
| 2024 amendments coverage | Form updated | Comprehensive guide to the suicide/self-harm override, digital copy validation, and SDM sequential ordering changes |
Free Download
Get the South Australia — Advance Directive Quick-Start
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
Who Should Use the Free Form Alone
You genuinely don't need a paid kit if:
- You've completed an ACD before and understand the binding-vs-advisory distinction under the Act
- You have a single SDM (no sequential ordering complexity) and they live locally
- Your witness is a JP or legal practitioner you've already confirmed isn't disqualified
- You're comfortable writing specific treatment refusals that a clinician can act on without interpretation (for example, clearly naming CPR and the clinical circumstances in which you refuse it rather than writing "no heroic measures")
- You don't need to coordinate the ACD with an EPA or will
This profile fits roughly the same people who'd be comfortable doing their own tax return with complex deductions — technically possible, but you need to already know the system.
Who Should Use a Structured Kit
The research is clear on where self-completed ACDs fail. A 2019 study across Australian hospitals found that clinicians regularly declined to follow ACDs because the instructions were too vague to qualify as binding refusals under the relevant state legislation. In South Australia specifically, the Advance Care Directives Act 2013 draws a hard legal line: if your instruction can be reasonably interpreted as a general value statement rather than a specific treatment refusal, it's advisory — and advisory provisions can be overridden by treating doctors or your Person Responsible under the Consent to Medical Treatment and Palliative Care Act 1995.
A kit adds the most value when:
- You're an adult child coordinating a parent's ACD — the SDM acceptance sequence, witness verification, and family conversation logistics become significantly more complex when the appointer has early cognitive decline and you're working against a capacity window
- You live in regional or remote SA — the Barossa, Riverland, Iron Triangle, or Eyre Peninsula present genuine witness-access challenges, and the kit's verification checklists let you confirm a local witness's eligibility before travelling to meet them
- You're completing the ACD alongside an EPA — the two documents cover different areas: the ACD covers health, personal, and residential decisions, while the EPA covers financial, business, and legal-property matters. The worksheet helps check for gaps between them
- You want your refusals to be binding, not advisory — the Treatment Decision Worksheet provides clinically precise wording that maps to specific medical interventions, which is the difference between a document that controls your care and one that gets set aside
The Cost Comparison
An Adelaide estate-planning solicitor charges $495 to $1,430 for a complete advance care document set (ACD, EPA, and will). The free SA Health form costs nothing. A paid advance directive kit like the South Australia Advance Directive & Living Will Kit sits between those — less than a single GP copayment for the procedural guidance that bridges the gap between the blank form and the clinical standard your document needs to meet.
The real cost isn't the kit or the solicitor. It's the cost of getting it wrong: an invalid ACD means your treatment preferences aren't followed, your SDM appointment doesn't hold up, and your family defaults to the statutory hierarchy under the Consent Act — which may put a distant relative, not your chosen person, in charge of your medical decisions.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use the free SA Health form inside a paid kit?
Yes. The SA Health ACD form is the statutory document — it's the only form that creates a legally valid ACD in South Australia. A paid kit wraps that form in procedural checklists and drafting tools. You're still completing the same official form.
Is a paid advance directive kit a legal service?
No. A kit is a legal information product, not legal advice. It provides step-by-step guidance on completing the statutory forms correctly, but it doesn't draft bespoke legal documents or provide advice on your specific medical or family circumstances. If your situation involves contested capacity, family disputes, or significant assets, a solicitor is the right choice.
Does the 2024 amendment affect which option I choose?
The March 2024 amendments to the Advance Care Directives Act 2013 changed the suicide and self-harm override, digital copy validation rules, and SDM sequential ordering system. The free form was updated to reflect these changes, but the form alone doesn't explain how these amendments affect your existing ACD or your new drafting strategy. A kit covers the practical implications of each amendment.
What if I've already completed an ACD with just the free form?
If your existing ACD was witnessed correctly and your treatment instructions are specific enough to qualify as binding refusals, it's valid. The 2024 amendments didn't invalidate existing ACDs. But if your ACD uses vague language like "no extraordinary measures" or "quality of life" without defining what those mean in clinical terms, it may be functioning as an advisory document even if you intended it to be binding. A kit's Treatment Decision Worksheet can help you assess whether your current wording meets the clinical precision threshold.
My GP offered to help me fill in the form. Is that enough?
GPs can provide valuable clinical context — they know your medical history and can explain treatment options. But most GPs aren't trained in the legal execution requirements of the Advance Care Directives Act 2013. They can help you decide what treatments you want or don't want, but they generally can't verify the signing sequence, screen witnesses for conflicts of interest, or coordinate SDM acceptances. The clinical and legal sides of an ACD are complementary, not interchangeable.
Get Your Free South Australia — Advance Directive Quick-Start
Download the South Australia — Advance Directive Quick-Start — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.