Abbreviated vs Detailed Advance Directive in Yukon

Yukon's Care Consent Act (2003) provides two advance directive forms: an abbreviated version and a detailed version. They're not interchangeable — each serves a different planning situation. Choosing the wrong one doesn't invalidate your directive, but it can leave gaps that matter during a medical crisis.

The Abbreviated Advance Directive

This is the standard form most Yukoners use. It handles two things:

1. Proxy appointment. You name a primary proxy (and optionally an alternate) to make healthcare decisions when you can't. This is mandatory — a Yukon advance directive without a named proxy doesn't meet the statutory requirements.

2. General care preferences. You outline broad directions for your care: whether you want life-prolonging treatment in terminal situations, your preferences about comfort care versus aggressive intervention, and any specific treatments you refuse.

The abbreviated form works well if your medical situation is straightforward, you trust your proxy to interpret your wishes in context, and you don't need to address complex scenarios that require detailed instructions.

No lawyer required. You can complete, sign, and register the abbreviated form without any legal consultation. You need two witnesses (both 19+, neither your proxy nor their spouse), your proxy's signature to accept the role, and the Notification Card filed with Insured Health Services.

The Detailed Advance Directive

The detailed form is designed for people with more complex planning needs. It provides structured space for:

• Specific medical scenarios. You can address individual conditions — terminal illness, persistent vegetative state, severe dementia, traumatic brain injury — and document different treatment preferences for each.
• Intervention-by-intervention decisions. Rather than a general "no life support" statement, you can specify your wishes about CPR, ventilation, artificial nutrition, dialysis, blood transfusions, and antibiotics separately.
• Personal values and beliefs. A dedicated section for documenting the values you want guiding decisions in scenarios your specific instructions don't cover.
• Section 30 special authority. This is the feature that most clearly separates the detailed form from the abbreviated one.

Section 30: Special Authority

Section 30 of the Care Consent Act addresses a difficult planning scenario: what happens if you lose capacity and then resist treatment that you previously consented to?

With Section 30 special authority, you can authorize your proxy to:

• Consent to treatment despite your objections. If you develop dementia and resist medication or medical care that you rationally wanted when capable, your proxy can override your in-the-moment objections and consent on your behalf.
• Authorize physical or chemical restraint. If your condition causes you to become combative during necessary medical procedures, your proxy can consent to appropriate restraint.

This authority is significant — you're pre-authorizing someone to override your expressed wishes in specific circumstances. Because of that weight, Section 30 includes a safeguard: you must obtain a Certificate of Legal Consultation (Form 1) signed by a practising Yukon lawyer. The lawyer confirms you understand what you're authorizing and the implications.

Without Section 30, your proxy is bound strictly by your documented wishes and cannot consent to treatment you're actively resisting, even if the resistance is driven by a condition that's impaired your judgment.

How to Choose

Use the abbreviated form if:

• Your healthcare situation is currently uncomplicated
• You want to appoint a proxy and set general care directions
• You trust your proxy to make reasonable judgments within your stated values
• You don't need Section 30 authority
• You want to avoid the cost and logistics of a lawyer consultation

Use the detailed form if:

• You have a progressive condition (dementia, Parkinson's, MS) where future resistance to care is possible
• You want to specify different treatment approaches for different medical scenarios
• You need Section 30 special authority
• You have strong feelings about specific interventions that you want documented explicitly rather than left to proxy judgment
• You want maximum clarity for your medical team

Can You Switch Later?

You can revoke or replace your advance directive at any time while you have capacity. If you started with an abbreviated form and your health situation changes — a new diagnosis, a shift in your treatment philosophy — you can execute a detailed form. The new directive automatically supersedes the old one.

If you go the other direction (detailed to abbreviated), you'll lose the granularity and any Section 30 authority. Make sure that's intentional.

In either case, the new directive requires fresh signing: two new witnesses, your proxy's new signature, and a new Notification Card filed with Insured Health Services. Don't rely on amending an existing document — execute a new one clean.

The Resuscitation and Care Form Is Neither

Sometimes people confuse the Resuscitation and Care Form with an advance directive. It's a separate clinical instrument that specifically addresses CPR — it tells emergency responders whether to attempt resuscitation. It does not appoint a proxy, doesn't cover treatment preferences beyond CPR, and doesn't require the same execution formalities.

If you want to refuse CPR, you should complete both your chosen advance directive form (abbreviated or detailed) and the Resuscitation and Care Form. They serve different audiences: the advance directive guides your proxy and medical team during planned care decisions, while the Resuscitation and Care Form guides paramedics in emergency scenarios where there's no time to consult a longer document.

The Yukon Advance Directive & Living Will Kit covers both directive types, includes witness and proxy eligibility screening, and walks you through the Section 30 decision — so you can choose the right form for your situation with confidence.

See more Yukon guides →